Skip to main content

Politicians make promises on their stump — we watch and hold them accountable.

Help keep the record honest →Create an account

Compare politicians

Pick a politician on the left; the right fills in with their opponent — swap it for anyone. We compare their record and what they've declared, never their party.

Reset

Politician

James E. Risch

RepublicanJames E. Risch

U.S. Senator · Idaho · Republican

Compared with

Mike Crapo

RepublicanMike Crapo

U.S. Senator · Idaho · Republican

Suggested match — pick anyone to override.

James E. Risch
+90
Integrity
Office
U.S. Senator
District
Idaho
State
Idaho

+90 · Keeps far more than breaks

Promise scorecard · 12 tracked, 5 rated

  • Fully Kept4
  • Championed0
  • Partial1
  • Attempted0
  • No opportunity0
  • Ignored0
  • Abstained0
  • Misaligned0
  • Hostile0

Integrity Score: signed average of per-rating credit × 100, weighted by significance and evidence confidence. Promise-keeping is reported separately from popularity. Methodology is open.

Mike Crapo
+80
Integrity
Office
U.S. Senator
District
Idaho
State
Idaho

+80 · Keeps far more than breaks

Promise scorecard · 13 tracked, 8 rated

  • Fully Kept2
  • Championed5
  • Partial1
  • Attempted0
  • No opportunity0
  • Ignored0
  • Abstained0
  • Misaligned0
  • Hostile0

Integrity Score: signed average of per-rating credit × 100, weighted by significance and evidence confidence. Promise-keeping is reported separately from popularity. Methodology is open.

By the record

Sourced Layer-1 facts — what each official has actually done in office. Neutral: figures stand on their own, never scored against each other.

James E. RischMike Crapo
Roll-call votes cast858858
Voted Yea / Nay614 / 220625 / 222
Votes against own party0.36%0.35%
Bills sponsored (118th–119th)11746
Of those, became law01
Raised (latest cycle)$2.9M$2.2M

Sources: Voteview (votes), Congress.gov (bills), FEC (finance). Independence = share of party-line votes cast against the member’s own party majority.

Where they stand — declared issues

Issues where both have a stated position or a tracked promise, shown side by side. These are their own claims — judged separately from whether they kept them.

No shared declared issues yet.

James E. Risch and Mike Crapo don’t yet have any topic in common on which both have a stated position or a tracked promise — so there’s nothing to compare issue-by-issue here. That usually just means coverage is still thin. You can help add their sourced positions and promises.

StumpWatch is live, and the record is still growing. Many promises and positions aren’t tracked yet, and some features are still in beta. Add a sourced promise and help keep the record honest.

Help keep the record honest →